THE RISE OF NAD PRECURSORS AND “FUNCTIONAL MUSHROOMS” AND THEIR REGULATORY STATUS IN THE UK AND EU
New Food Supplement ingredients, such as the NAD precursors Nicotinic Acid (NA), Nicotinamide (NAM), Nicotinamide Riboside (NR) and Nicotinamide Mononucleotide (NMN) seem to be appearing everywhere now. But are they lawful?
In short, the answer is “No”, unless you happen to be sourcing from one of the very few companies which have Authorisation for only ‘one’ of the above – using “Professor Google” or the mantra “but so and so is selling it, so it must be allowed” are perhaps not the most appropriate or justifiable approaches if you come under regulatory scrutiny.
Our experience from market participants who contact us about these issues are as frequent in number as those who reach out to invite our assessment of their marketing and description claims that they make in respect of their products – and mostly only triggered by their receipt of challenges from Trading Standards or the MHRA.
These products are not alone in being the subject of current regulatory challenge – the same can be said for mushrooms: some (and in some cases some parts) are Novel Foods and unlawful as Foods or ingredients in Food Supplements, but do you know which?
It is correct to say that these products are widely for sale in the UK and EU, but in many cases the focus has been entirely on their performance, functionality, branding and marketing. In most cases that we come across there has been an assumption of legality rather than a knowledge of it and therein lies the rub – many are not permitted, and the regulatory authorities are not overly impressed with being shown screenshots of other equally non-compliant products as the evidence which underpins your belief in legality.
We advise a risk-based proposition to all of our client Brands – we explain the regulatory position as it pertains to their products and it is for them to decide what to do. It is our role to set out the position and for them to weigh up the regulatory risk against the commercial benefits of selling or not selling in particular markets.
In reality, the regulatory risk for those who are aware that they are selling unlawful products is minimal due to the chronic underfunding of the regulatory authorities leading to a lack of enforcement in both the UK and EU. We seek to counsel against what might be described as a very short-sighted view because, unless you are happy with a small business generating that “side income” (and we make no comment on the ethics of doing so) then when seeking to scale and/or achieve a future exit you may be constraining your ability to do so:
- at that future point, when you have spent blood, sweat, tears and sleepless nights perfecting the brand;
- you are engaged with the major retailers and the big online platforms;
- the marketing is in full swing (and at full cost);
- influencers are on board and generating those long-awaited viral posts;
- sales and the revenue are both going through the roof; and,
- you are about to take the next step – and grow (or exit).
The questions begin to come in thick and fast concerning the legality of the products, either by existing or future investors each conducting their Due Diligence before parting with their significant funds.
If this is the first time that you realise that the ingredient is unlawful and there is no growth, then it is crushing – financially and morally – and we have seen it all too often over the years.
Would it not be better to fully understand the regulatory position of your products at the earliest stage possible, such as during product development or when you are being enticed to widen your product range?
Knowing what ingredient that you can use, how much of them that you can use, what health benefits and claims that you can make in respect of them and the manner in which you can market them is, we would suggest, one of the most important elements of any new product’s development and should be the foundation stone upon which they are developed.
Engaging with people who can advise you on what you can and cannot lawfully do and outlining the risks, should you chose to proceed with an unauthorised product, should be seen as the starting point not the end point – the perspective and not the retrospective. Functionality is very important, branding is key and the marketing is crucial, but do not forget the basics which are the true benchmarks for real success.
Having finally opened the door at your retailer, wholesaler or investor, having captured the buyer’s attention and excited for this next opportunity for the growth, you do not want to be sitting on a call or in front of the Due Diligence team explaining to them why you are seeking to sell them an unlawful product.
Find out first, get the wind beneath your wings and truly soar.


